FOOD SAFETY FOR SWINE PRODUCERS

Morgan Morrow
Swine Extension Veterinarian
Department of Animal Science
North Carolina State University
Raleigh, NC 27606

Introduction

When you are busy breeding sows and feeding hogs it is easy to forget your customers, the consumers and their expectations. But they are your ultimate customer. If they lose confidence in your product, you have no market. They expect your pork to be nutritious, economical, and risk free. Pork is certainly economical and nutritious but, like most of what we eat, it is not risk free.

You have very successfully addressed the fat issue and now produce a leaner product than years ago but the risk of food poisoning remains. If the consumer thinks that other food products pose less of a risk than pork then, other things being equal, they will support your competitors: poultry, beef, and seafood. Presently, all pork products are considered as one product. That is, pork is pork and if I feel sick after eating pork I will probably consume less pork in the future. As branded products garner more of the market, buyers may discriminate and continue to buy pork, just not the brand that gave them food poisoning. Think how easy it is for customers to cross the road and buy from a McDonalds rather than a Jack-in-the-Box.

In this paper, I will concentrate on food poisoning, the most important food safety risk to consumers from eating pork, but remember that your customers consider pesticide and other chemical (e.g., antibiotics) contamination to be more important (table 1). To address those issues, you must enroll in the Pork Quality Assurance (PQA) program and follow its recommendations.

The Risks of Food Poisoning, Real and Relative:

The last time you had food poisoning--and most people have had it--it probably was just mildly inconvenient. You probably didn't realized it was caused by food. You treated it yourself, and you almost certainly did not report the incident to a doctor or any government agency. In contrast, severe or extensive outbreaks are aggressively treated, reported, and measures taken to avoid a recurrence. In some outbreaks deaths do occur but these are rare (table 2).

Table 1. Public and Expert Perceptions of Risks from Eating Food

Ranking of Risks by FDA and Scientists

  1. Microbial contamination or spoilage
  2. Malnutrition or overconsumption
  3. Environmental contamination (for example, by lead)
  4. Natural toxins (for example, aflatoxin)
  5. Agricultural chemicals (pesticides)
  6. Deliberate food additives (for example, preservatives)

Ranking of Risks by the Public

  1. Pesticides
  2. New food chemicals
  3. Chemical additives
  4. Fat and cholesterol
  5. Microbial contamination or spoilage
  6. Junk foods

Source: Adapted from Lee (1989).

Table 2. Selected Risks to Life in the United States

Cause of Death Deaths per Year Deaths per Year
per 100,000 people
Heart Disease 716,200 336
Cancer 365,700 173
Stroke 194,000 91.9
Auto Accidents 45,900 21.8
Suicide 27,100 12.8
Homicide 21,300 10.1
Lightning 120 0.06
Food Poisoning 10 0.005

Clearly, food poisoning is not a major risk to life, but that is no reason to be complacent. Reported figures are probably an underestimate because cause of death is often difficult to establish. And the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) estimates that 33 million Americans a year contract foodborne illnesses, resulting in annual costs of $420 million for medical treatment and $7.3 billion in losses from reduced productivity.

What Causes Food Poisoning?

Many viruses, bacteria, parasites, and chemicals can cause food poisoning (table 3).

Table 3. The Most Common Causes of Food Poisonings

Bacterial Parasitic Viral Chemical
Bacillus cerus Trichinella spirallis Hepatitis A Ciguatoxin
Clostridium perfringens . Norwalk virus Heavy Metals
Salmonella spp.* . . Scombrotoxin
Vibrio cholerae . . .
Clostridium botulinum (toxins) . . .
Campylobacter spp. . . .
Staphylococcus aureus (toxins)* . . .
*The two most common problems for pork

Where do Food Poisoning Organisms Come From?

Food poisoning organisms exist even in healthy hogs and can persist through the processing chain to cause illness in the person who finally eats the pork. However, organisms also can be introduced by handlers at all stages of processing, from your farm through the processor, distributor, retailer or food service establishment, and finally to the consumer.

Faced with a problem of this magnitude and pervasiveness, it is tempting to allocate the problem to others and hope that they will solve it. To minimize the risk of foodborne disease, packing plants should handle their hogs better and process it more carefully. Retailers and distributors should take better care and, for example, ensure pork is always held at the correct temperature. Lastly, and unquestionably most importantly, food service and home food preparers must improve the sometimes sloppy way they prepare pork.

What Can You Do?

There are two ways you can help ensure that pork is the safest meat. Firstly, ensure that the hogs you send to slaughter carry fewer foodborne disease causing organisms. And secondly, learn how pork should be handled to minimize the risks and educate those who are not so enlightened.

How hogs should be handled:

In recent years, the Dutch have tried to produce Salmonella-free pigs. The following measures were often effective on experimental fattening farms.

How pork should be handled:

Follow the directions for keeping food safe as outlined in Appendix 1.

Two Projects for the Future:

Trichina Free Pork

Ask anyone what they fear most about eating pork and they will likely say trichinosis, the parasite living in pork muscle. Most cases of trichinosis in humans are associated with eating wild animals, e.g., bear meat. When infected meat is eaten, it can cause a variety of symptoms including muscle soreness and swollen eyelids. For pork the problem is grossly overrated. Although the risk is real, it is small!

Surveys during the 1940s indicated that approximately 12% of the United States human population were infected, and about 400 cases of illness were reported per year. Through public education and restrictions on feeding garbage to hogs, human cases per year have progressively dropped to about 50 cases nationwide for the past decade. For swine populations, currently only about 0.6% and 0.4% nationwide and in North Carolina respectively are positive. Serologic tests were available to identify infected herds but are no longer sold because of lack of demand.

Given the low prevalence in North Carolina and our ability to identify infected herds I believe it is time to put some Carolina Pride in your product and make North Carolina hogs trichina free. Because the blood tests are not 100% accurate it is not possible to certify individual hogs free. However, if the test was available again, your veterinarian could blood test a sample of your herd and certify with 99% probability that your hogs are trichina free. To keep your herd trichina free:

No more broken needles in pork:

Recently, I have been shocked to find how commonly our customers find broken needles in pork. You know how it happens; you choose too thin a needle for the task and the animal moves unexpectedly. Magnets on the processing lines do not find all of the shafts; that's left to our customers. This has got to stop. Enroll in PQA to find how you can avoid this and other problems.

Fortunately, there is a product available to cattle producers and under development for swine producers that will eliminate broken needles. The system is based on an air gun that shoots a pellet of encapsulated vaccine or antibiotic into the pig's muscle. Hopefully, the system will evolve and become available to the swine industry.

The advantages to swine producers for adopting preharvest food safety programs include:

Take-Home Message

Producers must assume more responsibility for the safety of pork. Our customers expect a risk-free product and are considering their options. The popular press has already provided many articles on the topic and sensitized the public. You cannot expect the issue to just go away.

You can help by:

  1. Asking your veterinarian or extension agent to give your farm a "food-safety" audit.
  2. Learning how to handle pork and help others understand. Order copies of the USDA publication "Preventing Foodborne Illness" and distribute it locally. Call 1-800-535-4555.

It is up to us. In February 1992 the Consumer Reports magazine published the results of their investigation into the seafood industry. It was damning. We must take a proactive approach and work to improve pork before we lose our customers.Appendix 1

Keeping Your Food Safe

Shop Wisely...

Store perishables promptly...

Keep a clean kitchen...

Practice good hygiene...

Cook foods thoroughly...

Know the cold facts...

Adapted from "Keeping Your Food Safe" Virginia Extension